Tanakh English Translation

Get the JPS Tanakh (1917) on Amazon

The Devil of the eternal covenant has no reason to fear Mary

The thy Flame of Love post on Facebook is a masterclass in Christian Midrash—the art of reinterpreting ancient texts to fit a new narrative. From a Torah-only perspective, the idea that a deceased woman is a "threat" to a spiritual being created by God is not just unbiblical; it’s a category error.

Frankly the "Devil" of the Eternal Covenant is a vastly different entity than the "Satan" of Roman/Catholic tradition.

Here is the refutation based on the Sinai Source Code.


1. The Genesis 3:15 "Protoevangelium" Fallacy

Their Argument: The "Woman" in Genesis 3:15 is Mary, and her offspring is Christ who crushes the serpent. The Torah Refutation: The "Woman" is Eve (Chava), and her offspring is Humanity.

  • The Text: Genesis 3:16-20 explicitly identifies the woman as Eve, "the mother of all living."

  • The Reality: The "enmity" is a natural, physical reality between humans and snakes (the animal) and, metaphorically, between the human impulse for good and the impulse for evil (Yetzer Hara).

  • The Departure: To retroactively turn a biological ancestor (Eve) into a specific 1st-century woman (Mary) requires "adding to the Word," which Deuteronomy 4:2 strictly forbids.

2. The "Satan" of the Covenant vs. The "Rebel" of Tradition

Their Argument: Satan is a rogue rebel who "fears" Mary’s humility. The Torah Refutation: In the Torah and the Hebrew context of the Covenant, the Satan (the Accuser) is a divine servant with a specific job.

  • The Role: As seen in the logic of the Torah (and later in the Book of Job, which follows Torah cosmology), the Satan cannot act without God’s permission. He is a "prosecuting attorney" in the Divine Court.

  • The Fear Factor: Why would a celestial officer of the King’s court fear a human being who has passed away? The Torah teaches that God is Echad (One). There is no "dualism" where a devil is a rival king who can be "scared" by anyone other than the Creator Himself.

3. The "Humility" Paradox

Their Argument: Mary’s "Yes" (Luke 1:38) reversed the Fall. The Torah Refutation: Salvation and "reversal" of sin come through Teshuvah (Repentance) and Obedience to the Mitzvot, not through the "yes" of a single individual on behalf of others.

  • Deuteronomy 30:11-14: Moses says the Law is in your mouth and your heart so you can do it.

  • The Departure: The Catholic view creates a "Proxy System" where Mary’s obedience counts for yours. The Torah is a "Personal Responsibility System" where every soul stands or falls by its own covenantal alignment.

4. Revelation 12 and the "Queen of Heaven"

Their Argument: The "Woman clothed with the sun" is Mary. The Torah Refutation: The Torah and the Prophets explicitly condemn the "Queen of Heaven."

  • Jeremiah 7:18 & 44:17-19: The Israelites are rebuked for making cakes and offering libations to the "Queen of Heaven." * The Connection: When the Roman NT/Tradition elevates a woman to a celestial sign "clothed with the sun" and crowned with stars, they are resurrecting the very pagan archetypes (Isis, Ishtar, Diana) that the Torah was written to destroy.

Comments

Popular Posts