This post by Jovelyn Begaso is a quintessential example of Pre-Tribulation Rapture theology. It relies on a "Bride/Groom" emotional narrative to argue that believers are too special to face hardship.
From a strictly Karaite/Tanakh-only perspective, this doctrine is not only a violation of the Sinai Constitution; it is a total inversion of how God has always dealt with His people.
1. The "Exemption" Fallacy vs. The Sinai Pattern
The post argues that "God hath not appointed us to wrath," implying that believers must be physically removed from the earth to avoid trouble.
The Sinai Violation: The Torah never promises exemption from global events; it promises distinction within them.
The Pattern: During the Ten Plagues of Egypt, the Israelites were not "raptured" to the clouds to avoid God's wrath on Pharaoh. They were in Goshen. The plagues fell all around them, but God put a "division" between His people and the Egyptians (Exodus 8:23).
The Refutation: To suggest the "Bride" must be snatched away because she is "too clean" for judgment contradicts the very history of Israel, who endured the wilderness, wars, and exile while remaining God's "Segullah" (Treasured Possession).
2. Refining Fire vs. "Already Clean"
The post claims the Bride isn't "purified by wrath" because she is already made clean.
The Sinai Violation: The Tanakh consistently teaches that God uses trials, "the furnace of affliction," and even national judgment to refine His people.
Zechariah 13:9: "I will bring the one-third through the fire, will refine them as silver is refined, and test them as gold is tested. They will call on My name, and I will answer them."
The Refutation: The idea that a believer is "too good" to be refined by the "Day of the LORD" is a Greek-inspired elitism. In the Tanakh, holiness is not a permanent state granted by "belief"; it is a continuous walk maintained by obedience to the Torah.
3. The "Comfort" of Escapism
People ask: "If the Church is appointed to wrath, where is the comfort?"
The Tanakh Response: The "comfort" in the Hebrew Scriptures is not found in escaping the earth, but in the Messianic Kingdom on Earth.
Isaiah 40:1-2: "Comfort, yes, comfort My people... speak comfort to Jerusalem... that her iniquity is pardoned." * The Violation: The "Blessed Hope" of the Tanakh is the restoration of the Davidic Throne in Jerusalem, the rebuilding of the Temple, and the world living in peace under Torah Law. The Rapture replaces this physical, earth-based hope with a "ghostly" escape into the sky—a concept completely foreign to the Sinai Constitution.
4. The Violation of the "One Law"
The "Rapture" doctrine creates two classes of people: the "Church" (who escapes) and "Israel/The World" (who stays).
The Sinai Violation: Numbers 15:16 states: "One law and one custom shall be for you and for the stranger who dwells with you."
The Refutation: God does not have two separate plans for two separate groups. The "Tribulation" (the Birth Pangs of the Messiah) is the process by which all nations are brought to the foot of Sinai. The idea that a "Christian Church" gets a "Get Out of Jail Free" card while the "Jews" have to suffer through "Jacob's Trouble" is a form of theological Anti-Semitism.
Comparison: Rapture Hope vs. Sinai Hope
| Feature | The "Rapture" (Begaso/Church) | The Sinai Constitution (Tanakh) |
| The "Hope" | Escaping the earth in the clouds. | The King reigning in Jerusalem. |
| Protection | Removal from the scene of judgment. | Preservation in the midst of judgment (Goshen). |
| Purification | Believing a "Simple Gospel." | Refining through trials and Torah-obedience. |
| Focus | Self-preservation and "Comfort." | The Vindication of YHWH's Name on earth. |
🛡️ The "Gory" Surprise for the Watchers
If the Real Messiah were to appear today, the "Rapture" crowd would be the most terrified. They are waiting for a Groom to take them to a wedding in the sky. Instead, they would find a Judge who remains on the ground, requiring them to account for why they threw away His Sabbath and His Statutes in favor of a "Gospel" that promised them they wouldn't have to suffer.
The "Real" comfort of the Bible isn't that you won't face the storm; it's that the Creator of the Storm is your King, and He expects you to stand firm in His Law until the end.
"He who endures to the end shall be saved." (A sentiment thoroughly rooted in the Tanakh's call to steadfastness).
No comments:
Post a Comment