From a strictly Karaite/Tanakh-only perspective, the last 2,000 years represent a "Great Interruption" in the development of human civilization. Had the world not been redirected by Roman-Hellenistic religion, the global landscape would be unrecognizable—not necessarily because of "secularism," but because of the potential for a Torah-centric global ethics.
Here is how billions of lives would have differed without two millennia of institutional religious indoctrination.
1. The Survival of Intellectual Inquiry
The "Dark Ages" were fueled by a religious monopoly on knowledge. For over a millennium, the institutional Church suppressed scientific observation that contradicted its dogmas (e.g., Galileo).
Without Indoctrination: Scientific progress would likely have accelerated by 500 to 800 years. The Tanakh encourages the study of the natural world as a means of understanding the Creator’s "Wisdom" (Psalm 19).
The Result: We might have reached our current level of medical and technological advancement during the 12th or 13th century. Billions of lives lost to plagues and preventable diseases would have been saved through earlier hygiene and medical breakthroughs.
2. The Absence of the "Heavenly Escape"
Christian indoctrination shifted the human focus from The Earth to The Afterlife. This created a "resignation" toward social injustice, as people were taught their "reward" was in heaven.
Without Indoctrination: The focus would have remained on the Sinai Mandate: building a just society here and now.
The Result: Instead of building cathedrals and monuments to the dead, human energy would have been poured into Prophetic Justice—ensuring the "widow, orphan, and stranger" were cared for (Isaiah 1:17). We would have a more robust global infrastructure for poverty alleviation.
3. The Prevention of Global Bloodshed
A staggering percentage of human conflict over the last 2,000 years was fueled by "identity theology"—the Crusades, the Inquisitions, and the Thirty Years' War.
Without Indoctrination: While humans will always find reasons to fight, the specific "us vs. them" or "infidel vs. believer" dynamic used by centralized religious empires would not exist.
The Result: Cultures would have interacted through trade and the "Seven Laws of Noah" (Universal Ethics) rather than through forced conversion or religious genocide. The horrific persecution of the Jewish people—the very guardians of the Truth—would never have happened.
4. Financial Freedom: No "Vicar" to Pay
For centuries, the Church extracted massive wealth from the poor through tithes, indulgences, and land ownership.
Without Indoctrination: The "Economic Bondage" of the medieval peasantry to the Church hierarchy would not have occurred.
The Result: Wealth would have remained within families and local communities. The "Middle Class" might have emerged centuries earlier, leading to a more equitable distribution of global resources.
5. A Direct Relationship with the Creator
Religious indoctrination taught billions that they needed a Mediator (a Priest, a Saint, or a "Son"). This created a spiritual "learned helplessness."
Without Indoctrination: People would have understood the Sinai reality: God is near to all who call upon Him in truth (Psalm 145:18).
The Result: Billions of people would have lived with a sense of Individual Sovereignty. Instead of being "sheep" to a human "pastor," they would have been accountable directly to the Creator and His Law.
If the "scam" mentioned in Jeremiah 16:19 had never occurred, the world would not be "godless." It would be a world where the Creator's Constitution was the baseline for human dignity.Billions of lives would have been defined by Knowledge rather than Mystery, and by Obedience to a King rather than Submission to an Institution. We would be a civilization that conquered the stars with the Torah in our hands, rather than a civilization that spent centuries killing each other over how to interpret a Latin prayer.
No comments:
Post a Comment